Tuesday, February 11, 2020

1000 Books Project: Herodotus' The Histories - Books 1, 2, 3 Discussion

Finally! I know, I know. A week past what I said, but better late than never.

Book One:

To kick things off...
"Although the Persians regard the abduction of women as a criminal act, they also claim that it is stupid to get worked up about it and to seek revenge for the women once they have been abducted; the sensible course, they say, is to pay no attention to it, because it is obvious that the women must have been willing participants in their own abduction, or else it could never have happened."
Victim blaming since ancient times.

I'll admit this didn't really take off for me until the latter part of Book One. At the point of Cyrus's strike against the Assyrians at Babylon is where my interest started to perk up (though not to the point of ravenous reading. It's still slow going, for me anyway).

The description of Babylon and the temples made me envision a beautiful and rich city. What I really found interesting was the queen Nitocris. Her strategic diversion of the Euphrates River, and her building of the embankment, as a defensive system against invasion, was genius. Also, her clever tomb built over the busiest city gate as a trap for future invaders. A very cunning queen indeed.

Next, Cyrus set his sights on the Massagetae. What I found most interesting about these people were their custom of relatives sacrificially killing a loved one when they became very old, along with some livestock, stewing the meat and eating it. This form of ritual cannibalism was considered an honorable way to die (whereas anyone dying from illness were not eaten, but buried in the ground). I couldn't help but think that perhaps these Massagetae were the inspiration for Anne Rice's twins in The Queen of the Damned, who were of an ancient race condemned by the Egyptian queen for their cannibalism of their dead loved ones.

Book Two:

Herodotus talks about another part of the story of Helen and Alexander (Paris) which Homer omitted from the Iliad. In this version, Alexander is forced to sail to Egypt and is greeted less than considerately because his stealing Helen from Menelaus is considered an "unholy deed." Supposedly, Homer found this story not suitable for an epic poem.

I found the timeline of Egypt and its kings very interesting. I thought I knew a fair amount about the kings of ancient Egypt, but it seems possibly not. I plan to do more research on the Egyptian kings mentioned. I've always found ancient Egypt very fascinating.

Book Three:

In this book, the strategic overthrow of the Magus by the seven conspirators, including Darius, was the standout for me. I believe this was a cunning move by Darius to become the Persian ruler.

I'll mainly share quotes from this section.

Darius said this to his co-conspirators when they were plotting the overthrow:
"Where a lie is necessary, let it be spoken. Our objective is the same whether we use lies or the truth to achieve it. People lie when they expect to profit from others' falling for their lies, and they tell the truth for the same reason--to attract some profit to themselves or to gain more room to manoeuvre in."
Otanes, one of the co-conspirators, basically advocating for a democracy. Of course, he was voted down, but "Go him!"
"It is my view that we should put an end to the system whereby one of us is the sole ruler. Monarchy is neither an attractive nor a noble institution. You have seen how vicious Cambyses became and you have also experienced similar behaviour from the Magus. How can monarchy be an orderly affair, when a monarch has the licence to do whatever he wants, without being accountable to anyone? Make a man a monarch, and even if he is the most moral person in the world, he will leave his customary ways of thinking. All the advantages of his position breed arrogant abusiveness in him, and envy is ingrained in human nature anyway." 
He goes on, but the meaning is there. This was the reason George Washington did not want to be a monarch, and why the founding fathers decided against it when we became a nation. Too bad certain people would like it to be a monarchy again (American history, 2016 to present).

My final observation in Book Three...the science really was not sound. Egads. Case(s) in point:
"...a lioness gives birth only once a lifetime to a single cub, because she expels her womb along with the cub. The reason for this is that while the cub is in the womb it begins to move around, and since its claws are far sharper than those of any other animal it scratches the womb, and eventually, as the cub grows, it rips it to shreds, until by the time is is due to be born the womb has been completely destroyed."
What exactly were winged snakes?


So, what did I miss? Did you find other aspects of the three books equally interesting? Are you struggling with the read, as I am?

Share any and all thoughts in the comments.

See you next month for Books 4, 5, and 6.


Sunday, February 2, 2020

Book Jar/Book List Challenge: Randomize Your Reading 2020 - Checkpoint One #Bookjar

I did not draw any books from my jar, nor my book catalogue (list) in January. I had a lot of reading on my plate. How about you? Did you draw any books? Did you finish them?

Share your experience (and links, if you like) in the comments.

For February, I have drawn...

from the Book Jar - The Secret History by Donna Tartt
from the Book List - Sir Gawain and the Green Knight translated by Simon Armitage

I still have a lot on my reading plate for February, but I'm hoping I will be able to get to both titles. We shall see.

Have you chosen your February book(s) yet? Again, share in the comments.

Happy Reading!


Thursday, January 30, 2020

Update on 1000 Books project: Herodotus' The Histories

I'm just going to say it...this book is kicking my ass. I'm still woefully behind on the reading. One person who was originally going to participate on the read of this book has since dropped out. I can't say I blame her. However, I'm still going to slog along because...challenge accepted. Ha.

I've decided to revise the schedule a bit, and I will warn. I'm not sure how intensive my discussion posts will be because frankly I'm not entirely sure how my retention is going to be with this book.

If you're reading along, let me know if you are struggling as well, or if you have decided to drop out too. Don't worry. I won't fault anyone if they do.

Revised Reading/Discussion Schedule

January - Books 1, 2, 3
Discussion - I will aim for Monday, February 3rd

February - Books 4, 5, 6
Discussion - March 1st

March - Books 7, 8, 9
Discussion - April 1st

Hope this works for everyone. I apologize again for being so behind, and for the disorganization.

If you're coming across this post and want to find out more about the 1000 Books Project: Non-Fiction 2020, visit this post.


Friday, January 3, 2020

1000 Books Project - Herodotus The Histories Reading Schedule

Schedule change! First two books discussion will be moved to January 21st.
Sorry...I'm behind on the reading. Thanks for bearing with me. 

I apologize for being a few days late with this schedule. Last time I looked, I only have one participant (Thank you, Lucy), but hoping more will join in.

This book has nine books so I built the schedule around them. The introduction, timeline, and the back matter of the book are not included in the schedule, but feel free to read them (I plan to).

Discussions will be posted here on the blog. Feel free to stop by the discussions any time. Post your thoughts in the comments, or share a link to a blog post.

Reading/Discussion Schedule

  • January 1-9 - Book One and
    Discussion January 10
  • January 11-20 - Book Two
    Discussion January 21
  • January 22-30 - Book Three
    Discussion January 31
  • February 1-9 - Book Four
    Discussion February 10
  • February 11-19 - Book Five
    Discussion February 20
  • February 21-29 - Book Six
    Discussion March 1
  • March 2-10 - Book Seven
    Discussion March 11
  • March 12-20 - Book Eight
    Discussion March 21
  • March 22-30 - Book Nine
    Discussion March 31
The original challenge post with info and sign-up is here.


Wednesday, January 1, 2020

2019 Yearly Challenges - Wrap-Up Post #ReadYourShelf #Book2MovieRC #13WLRP

This is the wrap-up post for the 2019 yearly challenges I host...2019 Book to Movie, 2019 Read Your (Book) Shelf, and yearly challenge for the 13 Ways challenge.


  1. I am not continuing with the yearly challenge for the 13 ways challenge in 2020, but it is still a perpetual challenge. Look for the button in the sidebar and click it for full information.
  2. I've added two new challenges this year. Check out the links at the end of this post, or look for the buttons in the sidebar.
I'm posting the links to the 2019 challenges below. If you completed the challenge (or even if you didn't) and you post a wrap-up, please link up in the original linky on the challenge sign up post. When you put your name/blog name, just add "wrap-up." Like so: truebookaddict/wrap-up

Here are the links to the 2019 challenges:

2019 Read Your (Book) Shelf Challenge

2019 13 Ways of Looking at The Lifetime Reading Plan Reading Challenge

2019 Book to Movie Reading Challenge

Be sure to leave a comment on the post so I know you added your wrap-up.

In case you missed the sign-up for this year's yearly challenges, you can find them below.

2020 Read Your (Book) Shelf Challenge

2020 Book to Movie Reading Challenge

Happy reading in 2020...a brand new decade of reading!